The iconic artist has lent his support for the European Union to dismiss an initiative to outlaw the use of descriptors such as “sausage” and “patty” for vegetarian foods.
A Divisive Decision
The music icon has joined forces with eight members of parliament who have petitioned the European Commission, contending that a ban passed in October by the European parliament would tackle a problem that doesn't exist while slowing progress on climate goals.
The legislation would spell the end for the use of labels such as steak, burger, sausage or escalope when describing products made of meat-free ingredients. Proposed replacements include the less appetising “rounds” or “tubes”.
“To require that burgers and sausages are ‘plant-based’ should be enough for the average person to comprehend what they are eating. This also fosters mindsets which are vital to our well-being and that of the environment,” McCartney said.
A Longstanding Advocate
McCartney is one of the world’s most prominent advocates of a meat-free lifestyle. Alongside his wife Linda founded the Linda McCartney vegetarian products range in 1991, and he and their daughters Stella and Mary launched the global “Vegan Monday” movement to inspire people to reduce meat consumption.
These meat-free alternatives have been part of a global trend of growing popularity in products to replace meat, although funding has diminished since a peak during the global pandemic.
Industry Backlash
Yet with the growth of plant-based products has come a backlash, especially from the lobbying agricultural and meat processing industries, which are anxious about the possible impact of lower demand on jobs.
The European parliament ruled 355–247 to ban “meat-associated” names from being used on vegan foods. As stated by media, Céline Imart, a member of the centre-right European People’s party, told the parliament: “I accept that steak, cutlet or sausage are products from our agricultural sector. End of story. No lab-grown imitations, no vegan options.”
Wider Consequences
The letter endorsed by the McCartneys and the British MPs contended that the EU rules could force the UK into similar measures as well, because the markets and regulation are still so linked notwithstanding the UK’s withdrawal from the EU.
The EU has a well-known “geographical indication” system for blocking businesses from capitalizing on the titles of products associated with particular regions, such as champagne, Greek olives or Italian cured ham. But the bid to limit the use of generic terms is more controversial.
Linguistic Challenges
Several of the words that would be forbidden have flexible definitions. As an illustration, lexicons define a sausage firstly in relation to meat but secondly as “an object shaped like a sausage”. Even more problematically, the primary definition of “burger” is often given as a “flat round mass of chopped animal or plant matter”.
The eight politicians backing the letter comprise ex- opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn and former environmental party leaders Carla Denyer and Adrian Ramsay.